AI Is Literally a Scam? Separating the Hype From the Capability
AI Is Literally a Scam? Separating the Hype From the Capability The Scam Argument, And Why It Collapses Under Its Own Weight Somewhere in the last two years, "AI is a scam" became a load-bearing opinion for a certain kind of commentator. The claim usually goes like this: large language models do not think, they only predict the next token; prediction is not understanding; therefore anything built on top of prediction is theater, and anyone charging money for that theater is running a con. It sounds airtight until you notice it is actually three separate arguments stapled together and presented as one. Nick Saraev's response to this critique, in a video released under the blunt title "AI is literally a scam," takes the staple out. He argues that the accusation conflates a claim about consciousness (does the system have an inner experience, does it "really" understand) with a claim about output (can the system solve a problem it has never seen before)...